Raspberry Pi builtin WiFi keeps crashing

[SamStarfall]

Well, with the new firmware loaded in, I cannot crash it. I repeatedly downloaded a big file, and it just worked.
I swapped back in the previous debug firmware image, and it crashed within a second.
Switched to the newer firmware, and it runs without a problem.
Throughput is not great - 1.4MBytes/sec, but I have no benchmark to compare it to, and I have some reservations about my wireless router.
There was no extra debug output.
For a supposedly debug build with no fixes, that was interesting outcome.
Setup:
Pi3 is running a ether to wireless bridge, to allow a handful of ethernet only devices to connect to the internet.
Pi3 is also running a samba share, which is what exposed the problem.

I will let it run, and report anything interesting.

Cheers.

[jamesh]

Report passed on.

[DougieLawson]

I've upgraded all three RPi3Bs to BRANCH=next 4.14.12-v7+ #1075 with your beta test firmware and the extra cmdline.txt parameter. So far nothing bad has happened.

[superbob666]

Can I please get the link to upgrade, so that I can try it out as well

[jamesh]

Can I please get the link to upgrade, so that I can try it out as well

Its not an upgrade, is a debug only version of the firmware intended to help find the issue. Although so I thought. I would absolutely not recommend using it unless you are specifically looking for this bug. There could be all sort of performance issues.

However, if you are willing to help, PM you email details and I can pas on the firmware.

[robjak]

I have recently started seeing this issue.

Rasbian Jessie

I never has this problem before, but i recently update/upgrade and then added I2C and a DS3231 RTC.

Wireless breaks right after a read of temperature from the RTC and a write to a usb flash drive and then I run a 6 sec iperf and log it to the usb flash.

Jan 14 07:00:01 PI3 CRON[4358]: (pi) CMD (/home/pi/t.sh)
Jan 14 07:00:01 PI3 CRON[4361]: (pi) CMD (iperf3 -c 192.168.0.1 -i 3 -t 6 >> /media/pi/DISK_IMG/iperf_test.log)
Jan 14 07:00:06 PI3 kernel: [57031.316146] brcmfmac: brcmf_sdio_hostmail: Unknown mailbox data content: 0x40012
Jan 14 07:00:09 PI3 kernel: [57034.284514] brcmfmac: brcmf_sdio_bus_rxctl: resumed on timeout
Jan 14 07:00:11 PI3 kernel: [57036.844505] brcmfmac: brcmf_proto_bcdc_query_dcmd: brcmf_proto_bcdc_msg failed w/status -110
Jan 14 07:00:11 PI3 kernel: [57036.844512] brcmfmac: brcmf_cfg80211_get_station: GET STA INFO failed, -110

[JosAH]

Anything new from the Cypresss fron yet? Note that since I upgraded to the 29/11/2017 release, my problems were completely gone; my Pi's Wifi hasn't been down ever since ...

kind regards,

Jos

[superbob666]

I was having a lot of issues with the wifi, especially when accessing from S7 phone, it would crash within few seconds. I will try to update today and would report back.

@JosAH: What upgrade did you perform? Raspbian or firmware update or both?

[SamStarfall]

The updated wifi firmware is certainly a lot more stable - I have not seen the mailbox error (or any other wifi related error) since i changed to the new firmware, but every week or so the Pi3 would hard crash, no serial port, no network ping, no visible signs of life. I have nothing plugged into the HDMI port, so i don't know if it output something as it was locking up. There is nothing recorded in /var/log/messages or anywhere obvious that i can see.
I might investigate a way to safely power it down late at night, so it gets a hard reset every day.
Its not a solution or helping to find the cause of the crash, but it will be a reasonable work-around, I think.

regards,
warrick.

[jamesh]

The reports we have had here and on github seem to say this firmware has no regressions and appears to generally be better. So we are going to push it to the repos as our standard firmware.

If anyone sees any issues, please let us know, either here or on github.

[fresh]

The reports we have had here and on github seem to say this firmware has no regressions and appears to generally be better. So we are going to push it to the repos as our standard firmware.

If anyone sees any issues, please let us know, either here or on github.

Any idea on when exactly it will be pushed? I havent tried the new firmware linked in this thread so I'd like to wait and try it from the repos.

[jamesh]

The reports we have had here and on github seem to say this firmware has no regressions and appears to generally be better. So we are going to push it to the repos as our standard firmware.

If anyone sees any issues, please let us know, either here or on github.

Any idea on when exactly it will be pushed? I havent tried the new firmware linked in this thread so I'd like to wait and try it from the repos.

Guy in charge of that wasn't in today - wil ltalk to him tomorrow. A few days I suppose.

[superbob666]

Hi guys,

just to give update, I upgraded my Raspberry Pi 3 to http://archive.raspberrypi.org/debian/p ... t1_all.deb, and everything seems to working fine. Just yesterday, there was an newer firmware released, so upgrade to it, http://archive.raspberrypi.org/debian/p ... t2_all.deb after that it started crashing again. I haven't look in what changed, but as soon as I reverted back to firmware-brcm80211_20161130-3+rpt1_all.deb it works perfectly.

Thanks

[jamesh]

I believe the firmware that went live yesterday was a rollback to an easier, known working version since the latest one was having problems.

So no idea what might be going on - the one you now have does have some issues, but they are quite obscure.

[starjuice]

I believe the firmware that went live yesterday was a rollback to an easier, known working version since the latest one was having problems.

So no idea what might be going on - the one you now have does have some issues, but they are quite obscure.

Hey what news about this issue ? My Rpi3 is affected....

[superbob666]

any update on this issue ?

[Plainsman]

robjak wrote:
>> never has this problem before, but i recently update/upgrade and then added I2C and a DS3231 RTC.

>> Wireless breaks right after a read of temperature from the RTC and a write to a usb flash drive and >> then I run a 6 sec iperf and log it to the usb flash.


can add a couple of data points --
1) my pi-3b wifi was solid until I started using a USB drive;
B) it really went south using the SnapTronics ATA--->USB adapter plate with a 1Tb 2.5" seagate drive, to the extent that it's unusable. I'm using a 4A power supply the plate. This connects to the pi's USB bus.

I understand the on-pi wifi doesn't use the usb bus so I'm left wondering at a power issue near the wifi chip on the pi3.

using a Panda Wireless dongle gives me solid wifi at the cost of more USB bus use.

I'd hoped to use on-board wifi to relieve the USB bus, but it sounds like throughput isn't that great with the brcm chip anyway.

be well,
PM.

[jamesh]

robjak wrote:
>> never has this problem before, but i recently update/upgrade and then added I2C and a DS3231 RTC.

>> Wireless breaks right after a read of temperature from the RTC and a write to a usb flash drive and >> then I run a 6 sec iperf and log it to the usb flash.


can add a couple of data points --
1) my pi-3b wifi was solid until I started using a USB drive;
B) it really went south using the SnapTronics ATA--->USB adapter plate with a 1Tb 2.5" seagate drive, to the extent that it's unusable. I'm using a 4A power supply the plate. This connects to the pi's USB bus.

I understand the on-pi wifi doesn't use the usb bus so I'm left wondering at a power issue near the wifi chip on the pi3.

using a Panda Wireless dongle gives me solid wifi at the cost of more USB bus use.

I'd hoped to use on-board wifi to relieve the USB bus, but it sounds like throughput isn't that great with the brcm chip anyway.
E
be well,
PM.

What are the failure symptoms? Afaict, current 3b wireless should be working well.

[Plainsman]

My Pi 3b's system software is a bit of a mashup so I could have well missed the correct update.

I'm running ubuntu linux with a RPI 4.4.50 kernel built to get temperature monitoring and a few other things working.

I've tried rpi-kernel_1.20180417-1 and rpi-firmware-stable.zip from github but haven't found either to hold anything for /lib/firmware/brcm ...

rpi-update dies at the *** Downloading specific firmware ... step - I've had constant issues with github and my 600Kbit net connection.

apt update / upgrade of linux-firmware have me at 4.4 at the "latest":
ANC01:~$ sudo apt upgrade linux-firmware
[sudo] password for XXXX:
Reading package lists... Done
Building dependency tree
Reading state information... Done
linux-firmware is already the newest version (1.157.19).


I'd appreciate pointers to a download / package / tar / zip with latest linux firmware, brcm firmware or an article on the right way to do this ... I don't want to wipe things clean and start over with Raspabian.

I got the mailbox issue the last time I tried, immediately after installing my 1Tb seagate, tied to a USB port on the pi.

I'll lose the panda adapter and try this again. I posted my comments above as this really seems like an interaction with USB.

sorry for the verbage ...
thanks,
PM.

[jamesh]

TBH, the best thing to try is a new SD card with the latest Raspbian download. This is will prove whether it's your distro/setup or something else.

It's going to be impossible to set up a test device here that mimics your setup, so replicating the issue on Raspbian is the best bet.

[SamStarfall]

All my problems with the onboard wireless went away after the last update to the kernel. Previously, I would get at most a few days of operation before the wireless driver would crap out with a mailbox error, and then later with the debug firmware it would hard freeze after about a week. I had a I2C RTC connected, which I think made the hard freezes happen more frequently.
Then, I picked up the latest kernel, and it has not blinked since.

Code: Select all

root@pi3:~# uname -a
Linux pi3 4.14.39-v7+ #1112 SMP Sat May 5 12:01:33 BST 2018 armv7l GNU/Linux
root@pi3:~# /opt/vc/bin/vcgencmd version
May 11 2018 10:20:16 
Copyright (c) 2012 Broadcom
version aab36c8af1b6215d1b2d704cef981303a2f8022b (clean) (release)
root@pi3:~# uptime 
 09:48:57 up 45 days, 22:49,  1 user,  load average: 0.00, 0.00, 0.00

Note - I have not put back the RTC, since it now has better network access I have decided to just use NTP.

Warrick.

[pfink]

Was the fixed firmware also rolled out to Raspbian Jessie?

[rpdom]

Was the fixed firmware also rolled out to Raspbian Jessie?

Very unlikely. Jessie is old and not really supported.